Mike Shields at AdWeek.com does a great job today exposing some of the pitfalls of video advertising with regards to auto-play advertisements. In his article, he not only discusses the problem but calls out names of brand advertisers who were running auto-play video ads below the fold on low-quality sites, and the ad network who served them.
This is a colossal waste of money for these advertisers, who perhaps believed they were getting real in-stream advertising for their dollar. For advertisers who want to ensure this type of thing does not happen to them, here are some points to ask about - and get in writing - from your publisher or ad network partner:
• Pre-roll: should be served within a new player that launches, or only when the user initiates video play in an in-page format. Companion ads should be an available option.
• In-banner: whether user-initiated or auto-play should be served above-the-fold (the latter can be effective if done correctly). There should not be “stacked” creative on a page.
Advertisers should also employ technology that allows them to track completion of in-stream and user interaction for in-banner. Look for anomalies with in-stream completion rates for “fake”, auto-play pre-roll. Depending on the site, it can be off-the-charts good or bad. For in-banner placements, look closely at interaction rates, particularly with turning on audio. Low interaction can be a clue that the ads are never in view.

Good thoughts, and glad that article names names as we both know there's a ton of shady stuff that goes on.
ReplyDelete"Advertisers should also employ technology that allows them to track completion of in-stream and user interaction for in-banner"
The problem with that thought is that the ad ops/acct management teams at most places seem to be typically underpaid, undertrained, or straight out of college and know little to nothing about the technology outside of the monkey work of clicking a few buttons to plug something in. Anything outside of that realm and they're at a loss. Heck, it's still an issue these days trying to track actions when using more than one of the major ad servers, seems like one AM or the other doesn't know how to implement and doesn't know where to go at their company to figure out the issues.